Does Oseltamivir Really Work? ALIC4E RCT- Non-Industry Funded Trial
January 6, 2020
Written by Clay Smith
Spoon Feed
Oseltamivir shortens duration of influenza by 1 day. The effect on duration is muted in young, healthy patients (0.7 days shorter) and amplified in older patients with comorbidities (2-3 days shorter).
Why does this matter?
The effectiveness of oseltamivir has been called into question. Most of the RCTs, including a meta-analysis of these RCTs, were funded by Roche, and most of the authors were employees of Roche or had conflicts of interest. In the meta-analysis mentioned above, the authors did not have access to the primary data for 8 of the 10 RCTs. You really must read the BMJ exposé about oseltamivir. What does this non-industry funded version show? By the way, it might be helpful for you to reread the recent IDSA guidelines and refresh your memory this flu season.
It really shaves a day off the flu
This was an open label RCT in a primary care setting spanning three flu seasons, including patients over age 1 with influenza-like illness, over half of which were confirmed using PCR flu testing. They found that, in aggregate, patients had 1 day shorter duration of illness. The effect was more muted in young, healthy patients. However, in patients over 65 with comorbidities, the effect was magnified, shaving 2 to 3 days off the duration of illness. The downside to oseltamivir was a higher rate of nausea and vomiting. Prior studies suggested treatment within 24 hours may add greater benefit. This study did not confirm this and found nearly equal benefit if started within 72 hours. The big issue with this study is that it was unblinded. Placebo effect is very powerful. Patients knew they were getting active drug or no drug (aka “usual therapy”). The recovery criteria were self-reported and subjective (i.e. less headache, less achy). Treatment had no impact on hospitalization or pneumonia rates. This study confirms what prior industry funded articles have concluded – namely, that oseltamivir reduces flu duration by about 1 day.
Source
Oseltamivir plus usual care versus usual care for influenza-like illness in primary care: an open-label, pragmatic, randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2019 Dec 12. pii: S0140-6736(19)32982-4. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(19)32982-4. [Epub ahead of print]
Open in Read by QxMD
4 thoughts on “Does Oseltamivir Really Work? ALIC4E RCT- Non-Industry Funded Trial”
-
-
I certainly appreciate the writing of Ryan Radecki. However, I don’t think it’s is accurate to say those who were not tested did not have influenza, as his post does. Though a far cry from a PCR test, the CDC measures influenza-like illness as a key marker of outpatient influenza activity. In times of high flu prevalence, if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck…you get it. It’s also interesting that there was such a greater impact on shortening duration in older, sicker patients. We’re they just more susceptible to the placebo effect? Or is the drug actually helpful? I think this study adds new light. It has weaknesses, which both Ryan and I pointed out. I’m just not willing to go full snark and say this was all placebo effect.
-
Typo…were not we’re. Thanks autocorrect!
-
-
It works for everything! <a href="http://www.emlitofnote.com/?p=4569">It reduces non-flu duration by about 1 day!</a> We need an open label trial for bronchiolitis and pneumonia and croup! Heck, we need an open label trial for all febrile illnesses. This thing could be a gold-mine for Roche!